There’s a saying that “New York belongs to the world, not just to America,” and it rings true in many respects. Compared to typical American cities, New York stands out with its unique living arrangements, lifestyle choices, and primary modes of transportation. In this densely populated city, owning a home is a luxury, and not everyone can afford the expense of driving into the city.
The skyline of Manhattan is certainly impressive, yet when it comes to transportation, New York faces significant challenges—so much so that “traffic issues” serve as a universal excuse for being late in virtually any situation.
If we look at familiar cities as reference points, we find Hong Kong, which has some of the highest fuel prices globally, but its efficient public transit means that driving is often unnecessary. On the other end of the spectrum, Los Angeles exemplifies a car-centric culture where leaving the car behind is nearly impossible. New York finds itself awkwardly wedged between these two extremes—a society that struggles to reconcile public transit with car culture. Commuters here can’t enjoy the ease of driving, nor can they rely on an effective public transport system.
In response, politicians have started to devise various solutions behind closed doors. However, whether it’s introducing congestion fees that draw backlash or superficially patching up an already dilapidated subway system, these efforts do little to bridge the gap between these conflicting transportation philosophies.
Public transit options like trains and subways can actually be quite comfortable. The real barrier to using them lies in the lack of effective connections between people’s homes and transit stations. Residents often find the walk too long, and driving can lead to parking woes. The solution doesn’t have to be complicated; look at neighboring cities like Boston or Washington, D.C., which provide ample parking near commuter rail stations and major subway hubs. If New Yorkers could easily access public transit from suburban homes, who would willingly choose to sit in traffic all the way to Manhattan?
Unfortunately, we have yet to see any significant efforts in this direction.